Indeed, their breakup did partially stem from the distance, a sentiment they shared in April when they announced their separation. After all, Gerry had suggested a change to their initial plans of settling down in Charleston, expressing desire to split their time between the South Carolina town and his own home in Indiana.
“I didn’t want to go back and forth,” Theresa recalled. “I wanted to have an established base with a beautiful home together with Gerry and then go visit our children.”
While the disagreement ultimately turned into a dealbreaker, Theresa respected Gerry’s decision to maintain ties in Indiana, adding, “He loves his house and I don’t blame him.”
However, Theresa said the spark in their romance went out with Gerry’s new idea for their forever home.
“It wasn’t what we had discussed,” she added. “It did change.”
Theresa and Gerry aren’t the only Bachelor Nation couple to call it quits after the final rose is handed out. Keep reading for a status update on every romance.
