There’s numerous debate over what makes a excellent sandwich. Is it the bread? Or does the beef (or no matter is status in for the beef) subject maximum? We might argue that the solution lies in a 3rd, ceaselessly lost sight of element: the sandwich unfold.
Mayonnaise is a vintage to make sure, however the fastest path to a memorable sandwich is a condiment that packs a wallop of taste and without difficulty unites the bread with its fillings. Those are the sandwich spreads that Eater’s body of workers use to provide their home-constructed sandwiches an additional je ne sais quoi. Which isn’t to mention that you simply must skip the mayo (and even the Vegenaise) — as you’ll see, quite a few those spreads shine brightest once they’re mixed with that stalwart of sandwich building. Irrespective of their mayo content material, they all testify to the pretty and unshakable reality that there are as many alternative sandwich spreads as there are sandwiches.
Zesty Spreads
Coriander chutney has been a staple of my existence since I used to be younger and made my very own kick-ass tuna salad with it. Years and years later, I came upon the magic of slathering the chutney onto sliced-meat sandwiches. The highly spiced, tangy, quite herbaceous taste pairs so neatly with sliced turkey (in truth, my go-to chilly reduce). And sure, that tuna salad is excellent in sandwich shape. (Complete disclosure: I generally tend to get my coriander chutney from Kalustyan’s, which occurs to be owned through my uncle and controlled through my father.) — Nadia Chaudhury, Eater Austin editor
New York Shuk Harissa with Preserved Lemon
I’ve by no means been a large sizzling sauce individual, having in truth been too afraid to check out it when I used to be more youthful. However harissa got here into my existence extra just lately, and now that I’m a full-fledged grownup with extra complex tastebuds and no concern of spice, we get on nice. And this harissa from New York Shuk is among the highest: deeply flavorful, gently highly spiced, with an ideal thickness (some harissas are too liquidy) and a refined contact of lemon. To my spouse Daniel, whose circle of relatives is Moroccan, it tastes like a distillation of his mom’s highest dishes; for me, it’s the most efficient condiment for spreading on tuna sandwiches, pitas with shawarma, or actually some other savory substances sandwiched between bread. — Ellie Krupnick, director of editorial operations
Creamy Spreads
I exploit numerous tahini. The wealthy, earthy style of sesame seeds pairs neatly with principally the entirety, offering savory heft to thinner companions and a robust base to high-flying flavors. This is applicable to sandwiches up to salads and entrees, so long as your tahini is thick sufficient to not spill out the perimeters (and also you stir, stir, stir within the separated oil). It’s nice mixed with mashed pieces like avocado, and particulate substances like sprouts or chopped pickled greens, all of which is able to assist catch any errant globs. In fact it’s additionally nice on a pleasing seeded bread to enlarge the ones sesame vibes. I really like Beirut logo for the reason that oil and solids reconstitute neatly, and I will be able to get it in 2-pound tubs — like I stated, I exploit so much. — Nick Mancall-Bitell, editor
It can be thought to be very 2018-overpriced-deli of me, however I nonetheless suppose Boursin, the grocer Gournay cheese, is a top-notch sandwich unfold: It has the tang of a goat cheese and the smoothness of a cream cheese, with a truly great, savory basis. I in finding that sandwiches are ceaselessly both too dry or too messy; maximum must have a pleasing, semi-firm unfold on them, whether or not it’s pimento cheese, hummus, guac, or membrillo. Boursin works as each an adhesive for greens intent on escaping the bread — slaw, thinly shaved onion, sprouts — and as a creamy supplement to just about any protein. I in finding it really works specifically neatly with turkey or roast pork; garlic and advantageous herbs Boursin is going highest with roast pork with dijon, whilst shallot and chive enhances a turkey with cranberry sauce reasonably neatly. And any of them paintings effectively in a cucumber-Boursin tea sandwich. — Brooke Jackson-Glidden, Eater Portland editor
:format(webp):no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/23403410/2022_04_20_Eater_Sandwich_014.jpg)
Highly spiced Spreads
Giardiniera is scrumptious, with out dispute. Pickled veggies and sizzling peppers — what’s to not love? However whilst you’re creating a run-of-the-mill sandwich, becoming the ones massive chunks of carrot and pickled cauliflower onto the typical slice of bread is a significant problem. Input Marconi Scorching Giardiniera relish, a Chicago icon that’s best possible for slathering onto any sandwich, however particularly a DIY Italian pork or, sure, a sizzling canine. It’s great and highly spiced, with quite a few tang from the pickled veggies, and spreads simply, making it a very simple strategy to spruce up even probably the most fundamental of ham-and-cheese affairs. — Amy McCarthy, body of workers creator
Whilst it will be sacrilege to indicate that hoagies lack taste — sharp provolone cheese, meat after meat after meat, and a crunchy sesame roll supply wallops of moxie to Philadelphia’s staple sandwich — including Cento hoagie unfold handiest livens up an already best possible lunch. The combination of chopped sizzling purple and candy inexperienced cherry peppers steeped in tangy vinegar brings a sweet-and-sour spice up to wealthy prosciutto and mortadella, chopping during the fats to create a sensation all its personal. Although it’s a regional distinctiveness, it may fortunately be ordered on-line. Don’t be shy about spreading it on even the most straightforward of sandwiches, from ham and cheese to a turkey membership. — Dayna Evans, body of workers creator and Eater Philly editor
Mayo Mixes
Tutto Calabria Calabrian Chile Paste
I’m a type of individuals who is aware of mayo is objectively excellent in a sandwich however stays quite do away with through the concept that, except I will be able to combine issues in and speak to it an aioli as an alternative. One in all my favourite inclusions is Calabrian chile paste (typically from the emblem Tutto Calabria), which I most often upload in a ratio of 1 section chile, 3 portions mayo. Its stability of fruity pepper, tart vinegar, and provide however no longer difficult warmth provides oomph to the cheese, meat, or vegetables in my sandwich — whilst additionally making it more uncomplicated for me to simply accept mayo and its moisture-adding advantages. — Bettina Makalintal, senior reporter
Mrs. Miller’s Scorching Pepper Jelly
Absolutely the GOAT sandwich unfold is Mrs. Miller’s Scorching Pepper Jelly, made even higher (if you’ll imagine it!) through blending it up with a mayonnaise of your selection. (I’d suggest springing for Duke’s mayo in case you’ve were given it). Not anything valuable right here, no recipes or amounts — only a couple spoonfuls of every blended in combination and slapped onto any sandwich does the trick. I really like this concoction on deli-style sandwiches, burgers, and particularly breakfast sandwiches. The HPJ is unbelievable by itself, too: slightly candy, no longer too sizzling, and stellar immediately out of the jar. — Stefania Orrù, supervising manufacturer
Brooklyn Delhi Roasted Garlic Achaar
Even if I consume quite a few Vegenaise by itself, I additionally love the usage of it as a base for blending different condiments. One in all my favourite mixtures is Vegenaise and Brooklyn Delhi’s garlic achaar. By itself, the garlic achaar is magnificently fierce, and whilst I really like stirring it into more than a few dishes, it may simply weigh down a sandwich by itself. Blending it with Vegenaise, alternatively, tempers it simply sufficient that its savory warmth enhances no matter different substances are provide. I really like the usage of the mix on any sandwich with roasted greens and/or tofu; it additionally makes a median egg salad. Actually, it really works anyplace warmth and fats are referred to as for, which is maximum sandwiches. — Rebecca Flint Marx, senior editor
